Thoughts on the Gaborik/Carcillo fight

Fighters don't fight another team's star player, unless that star player blatantly instigates the fight. That's the Code personified. Daniel Carcillo, one of Philadelphia's resident tough guys, did a dandy job of breaking that rule last night after a pummeling of Rangers star forward Marian Gaborik that proved, among other things, how much of a complete goon Carcillo is.

The "fight" occurred at the beginning of the second period during a scrum in front of the net. Players were jostling around, as happens, and Carcillo and Gaborik somehow got tied up together. Carcillo was giving Gaborik the customary facewash, and Gaborik (to his credit) wasn't backing down until the beat-down began, when Carcillo's gloves flew off and he proceeded to absolutely destroy Gaborik with a flurry of punches. Both got five minutes for fighting, although it was perhaps the most one-sided fight I've ever seen.

Some thoughts on the "bout."

• Carcillo claims Gaborik dropped the gloves first. Indeed, looking at the replay, it's apparent Gaborik's right glove came off before Carcillo's, something that could easily have been accidental, as even after it came off he still didn't throw a punch. BUT, even if Gaborik did get the glove off first, Carcillo had no business fighting him. It was an easy victory, and a show of cowardice and poor sportsmanship. If he wants to fight, he should have taken on a tough guy instead of the other team's star, who by the way has the fighting acumen of the French.

• I can't believe I'm actually applauding Sean Avery, but good on him for sticking up for Gaborik later in the game. Not only did he fight Scott Hartnell, but just a few minutes later got his hands on Carcillo and held him accountable for his beatdown on Gaborik. This is what good teammates do for each other. I normally would consider Sean Avery the worst teammate in the NHL, but he did well this time.

• This leads me to my final point, one which hockey analyst (and former tough guy) Matthew Barnaby also made on espn.com after the game: Rangers defenseman Daniel Girardi stood idly by, not six feet from the fight, and watched the whole thing go down without lifting a finger. I don't care who you are or what the circumstances of the game are, if your star player is getting the crap beat out of him by another team's tough guy, you better jump in and defend your teammate. Third man in penalty? Totally worth it. What would have happened had Gaborik been seriously injured in the fight? It showed poor judgment on Girardi's part, and I wouldn't be surprised if he takes heat for it from his teammates, coaches, and other players. You stand up for your guys, especially those who aren't as able to defend themselves against goons like Carcillo.

In the end, however, this shouldn't be blown too out of proportion. Gaborik's a big boy and can handle himself. Life will go on. I will say this: I can't wait for the next Flyers/Rangers tilt.

Staal Assumes Canes Captaincy

Everyone knew Eric Staal would be the captain of the Hurricanes one day, some just didn't expect it to come so soon.

The team announced today that Rod Brind'Amour - the team's captain since 2005 - was handing over the 'C' to the 25-year-old Staal.

The move was not wholly unanticipated, as Staal has been considered the future of the franchise since he was drafted second overall in 2003. Many, however, imagined the 39-year-old Brind'Amour finishing his career as captain and Staal taking over from there.

In the end, GM Jim Rutherford thought it best to act now, while the team sits in last place in the NHL and has nothing to lose.

"This would be the best time for somebody to understand what it takes to be a captain when you are in as bad of times as we're in," said Rutherford. "Different people have different opinions as to you wait until the end of the season or when this should be done. But I really feel very strongly that doing it at this point in time - when we've started our rebuilding of this team - is to give it to the guy that's going to lead this team on for the next several years."

Rutherford said he and the two players have met periodically over the course of the season to discuss when the change would take place. Brind'Amour, who in 2006 led the Hurricanes to their first Stanley Cup, gracefully acknowledged the time was right.

"The timing of it was kind of the question, we all knew that Eric was going to take over at some point. To me personally, I thought it was a good time to do it. Just to get his feet wet. Me kind of handing the torch over to him is really an honor to me because I know what kind of good person he is. We all know what kind of great player he is."

A classy statement by a truly classy player. Brind'Amour has always been a team-first guy and is truly one of the greatest examples of dedication and perseverance that young players have to look up to in today's NHL.

The move is a smart one by the Hurricanes. Staal is taking over a team that is in last place in the NHL, meaning there are no lofty expectations he has to shoulder. (Remember, the same thing happened with Sidney Crosby when he took the helm of the drifting Pittsburgh Penguins as a 19-year-old).

Meanwhile, Brind'Amour - who will serve as an alternate captain for the balance of the season - remains on board and can act as a mentor and source of counsel for the young Staal, easing the transition.

The Hurricanes made the right move in what will surely be a drastic changing of the guard as the Canes look to refocus their image as a team. The one certainty going in to the future is that their franchise cornerstone will be leading them. They can at least find comfort in that.

Today's Enforcer

I recently read "The Code" - a well-researched but poorly written book about the history and importance of fighting in the NHL. Many were quotes by heavyweights with names like Twist, McSorely, and Probert, weaving their tales of having only one job: Fighting. These men were not counted on to score goals or contribute in any other way other than to drop the gloves in defense of their teammates. They played a couple shifts (maybe) per game, and were short on skill but high on toughness, loyalty, and selflessness. Coaches left a special spot on the roster just for a tough guy. Many made a good living doing this, and I respect them for paving their way to the NHL by doing whatever they had to do.

I would love to get into a futher debate about The Code, but we'll leave that for another day. Let's talk about enforcers, a dying breed of player. Actually, scratch that and replace "dying" with "evolving". In today's fast-paced, obstruction-abhorring, salary-capped NHL, coaches must trim their rosters down to the very best the team has to offer. This, in many cases, does not include players whose sole skill is to bash faces. Players must be able to play, hence the evolution of today's NHL enforcers. These are men that are equally willing and able to provide energetic acts of pugilism, while still being able to take a regular shift and contribute to the team.

Years ago, a guy like Tony Twist had a regular NHL job as a fighter (check out the link, a great mini-doc on the role of enforcers in the pre-lockout era). His job was to be a police man of sorts, making sure no one took liberties with his teammates. Other than that, however, Twist didn't do much (career games: 445. Career points: 28). You may find a few players of his breed still in the game, but they are quickly fading, being replaced by younger, bigger players with skills to match the brawn.

Let's look at the man who is perhaps feared more than any other player today, Derek "The Boogy Man" Boogaard of the Minnesota Wild. As a player, Boogaard has little to no actual talent. In 32 games this season, he has two assists, 55 PIMs, and is a -11. His contribution to the team? 6'8" and 257 pounds of pure terror. His towering presence intimidates to the point that he doesn't even need to fight that much. He may have a roster spot now, but his value to the team will continue to diminish as his lack of talent becomes more and more apparent. He also has a reason to be looking over his shoulder: Enter John Scott. The towering second-year defenseman is the same size as Boogy (6'8, 255 lbs), but has skill and a niche as a mean, crease-clearing defender who is just as willing to drop the gloves as Boogaard (watch him take out renowned tough guy George Parros here). When Minnesota has an up-and-coming forward they want to dress, who are they going to scratch? Yep, Derek Boogaard. Why? They've already got someone back on the blueline (Scott) who can do Boogy's enforcer job as well as serving as a pretty effective defensive defenseman.

Stay tuned for next time as we take a look at some of my favorite Modern Enforcers. Let's call it "Enforcers: The Next Generation". Guys that can knock you around, and still play a pretty decent game. Hint: Boogaard isn't on the list (but please don't tell him about this post, he scares the bajeebies outta me).